Daly Cherry-Evans returned to Brookvale Oval on April 14, 2024, playing against his former team, the Manly Sea Eagles, in a high-stakes NRL Round 4 match. Despite his presence, Manly suffered a loss, intensifying scrutiny of the club’s current performance and future prospects (ABC News Australia). The game underscored the club’s instability as it struggles to recapture past successes.
Manly fans vocally expressed their dissatisfaction throughout the match, initially booing Cherry-Evans and later calling for the dismissal of head coach Anthony Seibold following the defeat (Sydney Morning Herald). This public discontent highlights growing tensions regarding the team’s management and on-field results during a challenging season for the Sea Eagles.
Cherry-Evans described his experience playing against Manly at Brookvale as a “really, really weird” sensation, reflecting the emotional complexity of facing his former club in enemy colours (Sydney Morning Herald). His return evoked mixed emotions among supporters and players alike, serving as a stark reminder of the team’s storied past contrasted against its present difficulties.
The match also featured notable individual performances from Manly players Jason Touma Koula and Tom Trbojevic, who scored impressive long-range tries despite the loss (Sydney Morning Herald). These highlights offer some optimism but do not overshadow the larger issues facing the club.
With pressure mounting on both the coaching staff and players, the Sea Eagles’ management will face critical decisions in the coming weeks regarding the team’s direction and strategies. How the club addresses fan concerns and rebuilds morale may determine their ability to compete effectively for the remainder of the 2024 NRL season.

Daly Cherry-Evans
Brookvale Oval
Manly
Sea Eagles




